| Author |
Subject |
galois00
Registered User
(2/5/01 12:15:35 am)
Reply |
Which
edition of Breval?
Shar's catalog has two editions of
the Breval C major sonata listed--one edited by Stutschewsky, one by
Schroeder/Rose. Any
recommendations?
Thanks,
Dan
|
DWThomas
Registered User
(2/5/01 7:58:43 am)
Reply |
Re:
Which edition of Breval?
Well, my teacher gave me the
Schroeder/Rose.
(The value of this advice plus three dollars
gets you a Starbucks coffee 
)
I've not seen the other.
Dave
|
ruthann
Registered User
(2/5/01 9:52:49 am)
Reply |
Re:
Which edition of Breval?
Abosolutely the Rose edition. The
one in Suzuki book 4 is good, also. We don't have a starbucks, but
our local equivalent won't let me out the door for less than 4
bucks...it's a grande thing.
cello_suttonr@hotmail.com
|
ekifri
Registered User
(2/5/01 10:03:57 am)
Reply |
Re:
Which edition of Breval?
But if you use Rose editions, be
open-minded to changing the fingerings. He does some bizarre
things...
-eva
|
ruthann
Registered User
(2/5/01 2:25:38 pm)
Reply |
Re:
Which edition of Breval?
Hmmm... Not to me, but then I
studied with a student of Rose. I always thought his markings just
made good sense. Is that not the case?
cello_suttonr@hotmail.com
|
ekifri
Registered User
(2/5/01 2:42:59 pm)
Reply |
Re:
Which edition of Breval?
I hesitate now....
Uh, not to me.
I find some of his ideas to be strange in the extreme. However, I
will escape gracefully ;-) by saying that regardless of the editor,
one should always consider alternate ways of fingering and
phrasing.
Even if you ultimately go with exactly what is written,
it will be a considered decision rather than blind
obediance.
How's that? ;-)
-eva
|
ruthann
Registered User
(2/6/01 10:12:07 am)
Reply |
Re:
Which edition of Breval?
Absolutely! So you think his
fingerings are odd. I'm going to keep that in mind when I look at a
Rose edition. Maybe I'll learn something. A new perspective always
helps.
cello_suttonr@hotmail.com
|
Email This To a
Friend
Topic Commands
(Moderator only)